DorkNet/docs/recroom-2023-room-save.md

2023 client room-save flow

Wire contract for the 2023.03.21 client's room save, reverse-engineered from OGPDOMCNIFM.UploadRoomDataBlobAndSyncReload (RecRoom.RoomLoading.Runtime) and verified against dev server traffic on 2026-07-07. Diagnosed while fixing "Failed to save room" / "An error occurred" save failures.

Sequence

1. Upload room metadata — POST https://storage.<apex>/upload, multipart (File=file.bin, FileType=6, optional References). FileType 6 = RoomMetadata is new in 2023 (2020 enum stopped at 5=Invention). Small payload (~4 bytes observed for a dorm). Response: {"filename": "roommeta_p<player>_<guid>.bin"}.

2. Upload scene save — same endpoint, FileType=1 (RoomSave), payload is the scene blob. Response: {"filename": "<blob>.dat"} (e.g. dorm_p<id>_v<N>.dat). The upload response DTO is {Filename, Hash, OwnershipProof} — the client accepts both Filename/filename casings; Hash and OwnershipProof may be null.

3. Commit — POST https://rooms.<apex>/rooms/{roomId}/subrooms/{subRoomId}/data with JSON:

   {
     "UnityAssetId": null,
     "RoomData":    { "Filename": "roommeta_….bin", "Hash": null, "OwnershipProof": null },
     "SubRoomData": { "Filename": "dorm_p…_vN.dat", "Hash": null, "OwnershipProof": null }
   }
   

   SubRoomData.Filename is the scene save and must become the room's CurrentDataBlobName (and the dorm-state row for dorms). RoomData.Filename is the FileType=6 metadata blob.

   Response contract (deserializer NEOPBOMGIOG, mapper KMBHAKAHNGH): legacy {success, value, error} envelope where value MUST contain BOTH keys, non-null:

   {
     "success": true,
     "value": {
       "Room":            { …same DTO as GET rooms/{id} (BuildRoomServerDetails)… },
       "SubRoomDataSave": { "SubRoomDataSaveId": 0, "SubRoomId": 0,
                            "UnityAssetId": "", "DataBlob": "<blob>.dat",
                            "SavedByAccountId": 1, "SavedOnPlatform": 7,
                            "SavedOnDeviceClass": 2, "CreatedAt": "…", … }
     },
     "error": ""
   }
   

   The client parses each field then runs a Dispose walk (NEOPBOMGIOG.FKDDCNLJOLF, reached from the SaveRoom commit continuation) that dereferences the mapped children — a missing nested object or scalar leaves a null it NREs on, and the save persists server-side but the watch shows "Failed to save room". So the Room DTO must carry every key the FGCPNAACHIK mapper (GLEGPFFPDBE) reads, including the ones the include-masked GET rooms/{id} path gets away without: DataBlob, DataBlobHash, MaxPlayers, ToxmodEnabled, and a non-null RankingContext object, plus SubRooms/Roles/Tags/Stats. SubRoomDataSave keys per the JKIFFPPAJNK mapper (PELEHJLMKJO): SubRoomDataSaveId, SubRoomId, UnityAssetId, DataBlob, DataBlobHash, SavedByAccountId, SavedOnPlatform, SavedOnDeviceClass, Description, CreatedAt.

Server handling: StorageController.Upload (FileType 6 → UploadGenericAsync("roommeta"), CDN-servable) and RoomsController.SubRoomData → ReadSaveRoomSceneRequestAsync (nested 2023 JSON via BlobRefDto) → SaveDataCore.

Failure modes seen

Symptom (client)	Cause
NDIKGKCFOCG: An error occurred at UploadRoomDataBlobAndSyncReload, upload frame (KPLOPGMJOLE) in stack	storage.<apex> host not routed at the edge (Traefik 404 page not found) — the save dies before reaching DorkNet. Probe https://storage.<apex>/healthz.
NDIKGKCFOCG: Failed to save room, no upload frame in stack	Commit POST rejected — historically 400 missing_room_data_filename because the server parsed only the flat 2020 body and missed SubRoomData.Filename.
NDIKGKCFOCG: Failed to save room preceded by a NullReferenceException at NEOPBOMGIOG.FKDDCNLJOLF	Commit returned 200 but value wasn't {Room, SubRoomDataSave} — the save actually persisted; only the response parse failed.

Room clone (2023)

The in-room "copy room" flow (RoomModel.CopyRoom → RecNet.Runtime NLDBPDCNNCF.GDHIIAHCBMN) POSTs roomserver/rooms/{id}/clone with an x-www-form-urlencoded name=… body — the same roomserver/ prefix as every other room mutation from that client. A bare-only rooms/{id}/clone route 404s with an empty body, which the client's promise layer surfaces as a message-less Failed to copy room: Exception of type 'CEMNLBKJABA' was thrown. The response must be the FULL room-details object (FGCPNAACHIK, same shape as GET roomserver/rooms/{id}), not a status wrapper.

Blob semantics on clone (RoomsModerationController.BareClone):

• First-party template source (IsAGRoom + system-owned, e.g. the RecCenter seed): the clone keeps the copied scenes but gets a fresh empty blob (CurrentDataBlobName/scene DataBlobName cleared). Any blob on the template row is a MakerPen overlay against the shared baked scene and must not leak into clones; AG room details also require an empty DataBlobName on the wire.
• User-owned source (including AG-flagged clones of RROs): blobs are copied so "copy room" carries the player's MakerPen edits.

Clones are created private (Accessibility=0) regardless of the source's visibility; the owner publishes via rooms/{id}/accessibility when ready.

Sub-room saves list is a PAGED OBJECT

GET rooms/{id}/subrooms/{sub}/saves (and …/saves/no_unity_assets) must return {"Results":[…],"TotalResults":N} — PagedResultsDTO<SubRoomDataSaveDTO> per the Studio decompile (RRStudio-decomp/...RecNet/PagedResultsDTO.cs); the 2023 client's GetSubRoomDataSaves sends skip/take and its strict reader throws expected:'{', actual:'[' on a bare array. Because callers run inside larger flows, the bare-array bug surfaced as "Failed to copy room: Exception of type '…' was thrown" (clone) and a dead private-instance button — not as a saves error.

Private rooms: one instance per sub-room

Private rooms (Accessibility=0) allow exactly ONE instance per sub-room. GoToController.ApplyNewInstanceAsync funnels every join mode (plain matchmake, JoinMode=1 new-public, JoinMode=2 new-private) into the same deterministic invite-gated instance (PrivateInstanceService.EnsureForPrivateRoomAsync, id marker 0xEE0000, keyed on room+subroom — dorms keep their own 0xDD0000 flow). Joins by players who are neither the creator, an accepted role-holder (co-owner/mod/host), nor an instance invitee return errorCode=4 (RoomDoesNotExist) so private rooms don't leak their existence. Tests: PrivateRoomInstanceTests.cs.

Baked Rec Room Originals and data blobs (Rec Royale)

Baked RRO rooms are seeded with empty DataBlobName / CurrentDataBlobName, which the details builders and matchmaking resolvers pass through as an empty DataBlob. The 2023 client treats that as "no room data": it never downloads a blob, so the room has no room roles (no Maker Pen even though the CDN overlays permissive roles for AG rooms), no CV2 room-settings chips, no mood engine and nothing to save into. IsRRO (= IsAGRoom) is independent of the blob, so a baked room CAN carry one: the client loads the baked map from its own assets and layers the blob's persistence views on top — exactly how Rec Center behaves.

Rec Royale needs this to be a game at all: the Frontier scene has no baked game rule (contrast PaintballTeamBattle_GameRuleWrapperCircuit, which is baked into the paintball scene). Its rule is the Maker Pen chip RecRoyaleSolos_GameRuleWrapperCircuit / RecRoyaleSquads_GameRuleWrapperCircuit (BattleRoyaleGameRuleWrapper : GameRuleCircuitWrapperTool), which real Rec Room delivered inside the room blob. Without it there is no BattleRoyaleManager in the scene.

Stub shape matters. Until something is saved the CDN synthesises the blob, and the client fetches it through RecNet.Rooms.GetRoomData and rejects one it deems unusable — a clone surfaces that as the bare "Failed to copy room", a baked room as a silent load with no room roles (no Maker Pen). Compared against Rec Center's working room_100_v1.dat, the old stub was stamped PersistedRoomVersion 19 (client ceiling 16; only the S3-hit path clamped) and lacked the save skeleton (last_save_time, activity_id = LocationReplicationId, connectable graph, scene settings, object model, room_mood_*). RoomDataBlobService.BuildRroEditableBlob now emits that skeleton per room at version 16.

Second requirement — game-role objects. Both reference saves carry three PersistenceViewData entries whose game_role_node_data (field 50) holds a PlayerGameRoleData: the room's default role (Rec Center: "Rec Center", Stunt Runner: "StuntRunner"; GUID c48bac02-… in both), "In-Game" (role_id 2097152, GUID 2c721342-…) and "Eliminated" (role_id 4194304, rank 1015, can_move false, GUID 0b9ec39e-…). Their spawnable_tool_data.prefab_id is the GameRoleNode chip prefab (c46e1535… raw). Since 2023 permissions hang off the player's GameRole, a blob without these leaves a co-owner with no Maker Pen. The stub now generates Rec Royale's own set (view ids derived from the activity id).

Admin switch: POST api/admin/v1/rooms/{id}/subrooms/{sub}/blob/enable stamps RoomService.SyntheticDefaultRoomDataBlobName(id) on the scene and room; .../blob/reset clears it. See docs/admin.md → "RRO room data blob" for the full procedure (enable → spawn the game-rule chip → save).

Related 2023 quirks fixed alongside

• Play-menu search (IBEOONPEELF.SearchRooms): calls rooms/search_rooms/{query}&skip={n}&take={n} — rooms/-prefixed AND paging embedded in the final path segment. Same segment style on hot_rooms, hot_roomsandplaylists, search_roomsandplaylists (parsed by RoomsController.ParsePagedPathSegment).
• Room photo gallery (KLJOGJHBONK, "Could not show images for room"): api/images/v{2-5}/room/{id}?sort=CheerCount_Desc&filter=PublicOnly — sort/filter arrive as enum NAMES; binding them as int makes [ApiController] auto-400. Bound as strings, mapped in ImagesController.ParseSort.

Tests: DorkNet.Server.Tests/RoomSave2023Tests.cs, DorkNet.Server.Tests/RoomBrowse2023Tests.cs.